Holsten Pills Larger Calories

The irretrievable mess of Pompeii and the inability 'POLICY OF THE MINISTRY OF BONDI IN THE MANAGEMENT MiBAC


The failure of the Commissioners and City Manager

With the collapse of the Schola Armaturarum, it is up to the disaster waiting to happen, the last in order of time, since a few days earlier had already collapsed by dragging with it a wall huge mass of volcanic material in the House of the Chaste Lovers, this poses an urgent problem of security in the excavations of Pompeii and the management of the Archaeological Superintendence of Naples and Pompeii.
The collapse is the stark reality that can no longer hide the mismanagement of the most popular archaeological site in the world. The action is unfolding with all its threat came from afar, with the introduction of city-manager at the hands of various governments, until the last situation that has introduced, that of the commissioner by the Civil Defence. All these are
, unlined by the various governments in turn, have been pursued as an excuse to highlight the image of the government and resolve the emerging of the most important Superintendents. The pressure exerted by the Government on the major "cultural deposits" have in fact weakened the Bureaus, which play an important role even to protect the territory from attacks by building, of local mafias, and political interference, which unfortunately put the weak, making them pay in a perpetual crisis, almost bordering on paralysis of the same.
The bad policy of this government aims to privatize the Public Administration and blocking the turn-over appeal with the award of work and services directly to individuals. This has seen the depletion of the offices and the transformation of work, which unfortunately has given rise to the chronic state of neglect and lack of servicing. In so doing entire workforce of manual workers (masons, plumbers, carpenters, painters, blacksmiths) were canceled through a retraining program ministerial shameful that instead of transforming the roles of unskilled workers in skilled, which would give dignity to the workers restoring the right identity, paradoxically, assigned them to tasks and functions of engineers, effectively depriving them of their former cultural and professional knowledge.
Accordingly, the hand of the Commissioner for Civil Defence has proven completely bankrupt, has served as the means of propaganda of the mass media, through appropriately designed ad hoc spot, gave the public a distorted view of reality. For this
for Confsal-UNSA Cultural Heritage emphasizes the need to have a broader political vision, which may result in a union with regard to mobilization and open at the same time a broad national dispute, which bring out Superintendents of all the problems of Italy. This strategically organized
dispute must lead to a single claim, by overcoming the differences of the various political parties and trade unions, in order to develop a core curriculum which covers the following points:
refurbish the offices of Superintendents and prepare a plan of reorganization human resources;
Reconstitute teams of workers through a training period in order to specialize in different quality builders, plumbers, restorers, carpenters, etc.;
Intensify supervision with adequate turn-over and integrating the profiles with new intakes unemployed youth and unemployed.
necessary that the head of the department should send more money for culture, as it is unthinkable that the Ministry intended to be only 0.22 percent of the state budget, less than any European state. On average, others are at 0.35 and someone comes 1 per cent. In financial
there was a cut of 1.7 billion euro to the culture. A mortal blow.
Our whole economic measure contains cuts for 24 billion euro, Germany has cut a total of 80 billion, but has invested 15 in culture. In Italy instead for cultural funding are being cut and will continue to be cut. Pompeii
teaches us that we have a heritage too important to safeguard against a reality of the budget very difficult and will continue to be so disastrous choices for the current government.
E 'therefore need to radically change the way you manage the cultural assets in Italy, it should be a responsibility at various levels who can identify the priorities that emerged strongly after yet another mess that was made at Pompeii.

Mom Went For The Hairbrush

REFLECTIONS ON THE REVIEW AND OUTLOOK


scenario political, financial and economic of the country and in such a profound change that is difficult to predict the outcome. One thing is certain: 2011 will continue to be a year of concern for the heavy economic crisis still ongoing in the country.
indefinable dimensions of the financial crisis, no boundaries and limits for the global characteristics that govern it, has disrupted the traditional reference points on which rested the social and economic policy of the country.
The two major party political poles are very difficult to link to them for not recognizing in harmony on a few issues that are drawn from organizations with different cultures.
If the opposition loses firmness because, for example, in the Democratic Party with the various social and political culture presents problems of coexistence with the political structure whose components push further for the identification of a new leadership, while the other part opponents send warning signals to the constitution the so-called center, so as to make feasible third political pole. In this play, the old reading in the political history of our country, it is difficult role of the union that could see the affected units for the different radicalism that could aggravate.
"union tends to lose its identity because the former feels the failure to fill the needs of a changing society to which it spreads in the various organizations by organizing the search for new spaces, such as the CISL, specific arrangements with associations Forum religious beliefs or socio-ideological interests aiming to involve more widespread and involving.
Faced with a possible reduction in the role of the union, resulting in a relapse of the acquisition of withholding registration of a trade union and "rationalization" of freedom of association, it calls for serious reflection on the search for alternative or supplementary funding through the development of social welfare services.
The governments of the new companies have lost sight of "the person" who is no longer the center of the association rules and this decline in the union seeking an identity difficult to detect. It 's impossible to claim new economic resources to reopen labor contracts locked up until 2013 at the behest of government, at the same time when masses of workers lose their jobs, or combine with the specific demands of subsidiarity.
II decentralization, better known as federalism, changing the structures of state and solidarity among local authorities is not done in a centralized one-act play, because that becomes a mutual search for local subsidiarity;
If federalism rendering the decision-making center of Rome's decision to increase the operating edge, just to be closer to the problems of citizens, including the union should otherwise characterize their structural organization by giving more space to the periphery and reducing the central
cl1e differences still exist today in many ways , particularly in the autonomous unions, need to be better disciplined and focused to interpret more effectively the needs and expectations of workers and
I'evasione I'elusione tax, undeclared work and child are an endemic evil that must still be eliminated, or at least reduced, because resources are diverted from public a social and moral offense that can no longer be allowed at a time of economic crisis and social suffering;
leading to a simplified picture union and a goal to achieve because it is no longer tolerable to persist in the season long contract, late and disharmony.
By Stefano Innocentini

Cervical Mucos One Day Before Menstruation

DISASTER! Disgust and shouted''Shame!


Yesterday, I was on November 7, 2010 Pompeii where I spoke to the Minister Bondi of 4 houses that I think unsafe. I told all the journalists present. They are in my opinion of an archaeologist: The House of the Silver Wedding, The House of the Labyrinth, The House of the Moralist, The House of Julia Felix.
For years, as an archeology student, then an archaeologist, I am free, and stress free, Pompeii. I have always referred to as an awkward figure. Notes are my grievances in the endless (endless for my detractors) that I spend days on excavations inspecting every corner. In fact, I have always criticized lax and incompetent in my written and oral reports. But I do not care and went on my way screaming the truth that comes from the respect I have for this ancient World Heritage city. And now this latest scandal. The collapse of Shola Armaturarum, presumably occurred around 6 am on 6 November. The area is cordoned off hours and was set up alternative tourist route to reach Port Amphitheater. The causes of structural failure investigations are in progress. The Domus Schola Armatorum is called, as it took place in the training of the gladiators of which were kept inside the armor. A first hypothesis on the causes of the collapse is about possible infiltration of water due to rains that have raged in recent days over the city and proximity to the Domus an embankment. The collapse has affected the vertical walls of the Schola, which had been rebuilt in the fifties and now are completely destroyed.
probably be saved, however, the paintings that occupied the lower part of the house to a height of about m.1, 50. The damage to 'image abroad is incalculable because the country confirms the land of ignorance, of scandals and prostitutes. In January there had been a collapse in the house of the Chaste Lovers, then the damage to Thermopolium end of September and another incident in the house of Julius Polybius. I join the cry of shame that President Napolitano has used harsh words.
"What that has happened we must all feel like a disgrace to Italy and who must give an explanation does not shirk the duty to give her as soon as possible and without hypocrisy. " Schola Armaturarum was not returned to the upper floors of restoration that cost 79 million euro well in two years of which 90% was spent on the protection and the safety of the ancient city. A second appropriation of 39 million would include the restoration of Villa dei Misteri, the Fullonica, Home dell'Efebo of Loreio Tiburtino of Criptoportico, Venus in the shell of Julia Felix, the ancient beach of Herculaneum and the Villa of Poppea to Oplontis. Two million euro have been earmarked for routine maintenance of websites. Among the recent restoration of the House of Julius Polybius, and that of the Domus of the Chaste Lovers, brought to light in 1987, she, my mistress, to which I devoted two long chapters in my Essay of archaeological Temple. The house was badly damaged in January 2010, said to a landslide. Other homes recently restored and opened to the public are to Obellio signature, the house of Marcus Lucretius Fronto, the house of Sallust, the maximum air home and the home of the Golden Cupids, Casca Longus's house, the home of the Four Styles , which sums up its frescoes by the four styles of Pompeian painting, the Thermopolium Lucius Vetutius Placidus and the house of Menander. For all questions relating
interviews, rights, options and more, contact the Office of Rita Bellacosa at: segreteria.ritabellacosa
@ gmail.com All rights reserved.
Rita Bellacosa

Breast Size Average By Nationality

''POMPEII: THE GLADIATORS GYM. Brothels E!


receive and publish

In these days there is much talk of the collapse of the gymnasium of the gladiators in Pompeii. Indeed, it has become a national case so as to become the last tile, possibly fatal to the Berlusconi government. Yeah, because they are rarely asked for the resignation of a minister of Culture for the collapses on our artistic heritage. Mind you, the fact itself is nothing short of serious and in all cases situation is no longer collapsed from decades of neglect and policies purely speculative. Bondi If this minister has a responsibility (and not only on the last episode of Pompeii) is right for him to leave unceremoniously. But what kind of responsibility can have a minister in this context? Why all this great clamor against Bondi, nobody has ever even place the responsibilities of supervisors and city manager for ten years come from? Is it possible that nobody has asked the question of the conduct and responsibilities of scientific and managerial supervision of Pompeii, where he worked for ten years and city supervisors - manager? No one remembers when former superintendent Guzzo thundered through the press that the evils of that site malaffari but were not the custodial staff, which was privatized as soon as possible? Why, apart from some isolated union, none of these contemporary moral cried scandal, demanding the immediate removal of Guzzo, when it was discovered that his wife was on the Board of Directors "Electra," contractor in that of Pompeii and Rome , with slopes of judicial handling of illegal settlements on the spot, so that the then deputy Alfano asked the intervention of the inspectors? Nobody has ever asked the disastrous consequences of the sad-city-manager management supervisor, real blow de grace to the decades of problems at Pompeii, with such a waste of money and progressive deterioration, to the point of having to commissioners? And if we go to Pompeii Archaeological Superintendence of Rome, we see that more in the last decade, the Domus Aurea, there were four crashes (twice on the structures of the site and twice in the trees of the garden) and always by a miracle victims have not complained about the public and staff ASV
Indeed, the superintendent at the time, The Queen and the former Minister Melandri, who succeeded Veltroni, all three PD targati minimized by declaring to the world that it was only a " very slight "give (sic). Last fall took place last March showed how they can be "very slight" certain crashes (!) Ditto on the Palatine where a few years ago broke down a wall adjacent to the path to the public and always a miracle there was a massacre. Moral of the story? No one has paid for their responsibilities: supervisors, technical and scientific directors, responsible for safety and all those that rotate (paid handsomely, of course!) To great crib that goes under the name of "restoration, maintenance and enhancement of cultural heritage. " We are not some of us to defend a bond, or in political / administrative pulpits but from certain politicians, especially on the left Levin hypocritical moralists of arrows, just by the figures of a Veltroni and Melandri, well ... this is too much!
The truth is that the collapse of Pompeii is the result decade of political business is operated from the right and left, such as to reduce some of the superintendents in brothels, if we use a term ad hoc, with all due respect to a sincere and real political reorganization of our artistic heritage and enhancement of all personnel operating there. But that's another story ...
Enzo Lepone

Skidoo Primary Clutch Not Fully Close

PRESS STAMPAGIUSEPPE Urbino (AnsMode CONFSAL NATIONAL CULTURAL HERITAGE-UNSA) on Pompeii:

"BONDI HAS DESTROYED THE ITALIAN CULTURE.

OPPOSITION TO THE FUTURE AND FREEDOM 'TO THE HOUSE Mandino.

" How good Toto said, there are several categories of men and Bondi is part of the "ominicchi" that does not even have the courage to take responsibility and take the trouble after what happened to Pompeii - says Giuseppe Urbino, national secretary of the UNSA-Confsal Cultural Heritage - because all this time it was a real disorder that consumed in the Roman College at the head of the Pontifical Council for Culture. culture that has completely destroyed, which made it possible to halve the economic resources and the collapse of Pompeii, are the picture of the incompetence of our Minister of Culture.

Now the opportunity is tempting to send him home - says the union's Confsal-UNSA and the motion of no confidence that the Democratic Party in line with the statements these days can not fail to be also voted by members of the Future and Freedom.

To the Parliamentarians Fini, voting no confidence in Bondi - concludes Urbino - a demonstration that would eventually wants to turn the page in this country beyond the usual claims without facts. "

Rome, November 10, 2010

Tel 06 67232348 -2889

I Need Community Service Hours Fast

BONDI AND 'ART OF scrambling

"The utterances of the Minister Bondi Ballarò during the telecast of the November 9, 2010, regarding their responsibility for the collapse of the Schola Armaturarum Juventis Pompey, at least leave us stunned." This was stated by the National Secretary-UNSA CONF.SAL Cultural Heritage Joseph Urbino, who continued: "We have witnessed a painful scrambling that does not honor the institutional role that that plays. Among the utterances Minister, many of which are truly unhappy, we also have the not so veiled attack on the Superintendent. Maybe Bondi forget that the Superintendent 's commissioner two years ago and has therefore no longer independent. Moreover, given that the Minister really like the figure of the manager and invokes every where, in addition to legitimate doubt that this is the optimal solution, we recall that the Commissioner is already a super manager ".

Moreover, as soon took office, more than two years ago, has now implemented the 'yet another reform of the Ministry, we wonder, what is served, as at present,' only result was to assign seats to high lavishly paid bureaucrats of the State with the money of the citizens.

"The real problem," concludes the union, "is all that 'current government is not interested in culture, just think of the statement by Minister Tremonti or by the governor of the Veneto Luca Zaia . At this point the much-vaunted intellectual honesty and political Minister Bondi should apply to itself without waiting for further and resign quickly. "

Roma, 10 November 2010

Tel 06 67232348 -2889

The Queen Of Hearts Tutu

PRESS RELEASE PRESS RELEASE JOSEPH Urbino (AnsMode CONFSAL NATIONAL CULTURAL HERITAGE-UNSA) on Pompeii:

Bond fold.

stop destroying ITALIAN CULTURE. "

"For once, stop being a poet and a man becomes - says Giuseppe Urbino, national secretary of the UNSA-Confsal Culture Minister culture, Sandro Bondi - before being discouraged and after the stern warning from the President of the Republic, Giorgio Napolitano, who cried out of shame, the "yes man" of Premier Berlusconi, take courage and move on hand, a gesture that would finally earn some punticino seen that so far has only managed cultural assets causing great damage to the culture of our country.

Up Pompeii - continues the union - the policy of Bondi, if you can call it, was only to produce a series of commissioners who have not led for nothing but a series of failures and waste of public money and the consequences are also the story of today: in a continuous deterioration and collapse of the archaeological sites that the world envies.

Bondi - Urbino ends - has hit the bottom, came to an end, his "not policy ", under the thumb of dicktat of some of his collaborators, has given the country a reform of the Ministry liable only to occupy the seats and not to carry out specific projects for the revival of Italian culture.

The nomination for as the Director General for the Promotion of Cultural Heritage, Mario Resca, a failure on all fronts, where is the value? This appointment is so dear to Silvio Berlsuconi Resca that has benefited only got the sound of commissioner of Brera in a nutshell . And speaking of Resco, we are still waiting for his resignation from the many tasks that are in serious conflict with his position, is still Board of Directors of the Mondadori Electa and in the meantime continues to manage the tenders for the award of the additional services the Ministry of Culture. But this is government action to revive the cultural heritage that Italy could make a big deal?

Bondi, pass the hand is better. "

Rome, November 8, 2010

Tel 06 67232348 -2889

Are Bullet Proof Vest Illegal In North Carolina

FINGER AND THE MOON CONTINUES THE 'TO ATTACK STATE!

FINGER AND THE MOON CONTINUES THE 'CONNECTION TO STATE!

I Need Money Desperatly

SERIOUS RESPONSIBILITY 'FOR THE BIG DELAY IN THE PROCESS OF UPGRADING

SERIOUS RESPONSIBILITY 'FOR THE BIG DELAY IN

redevelopment process

continue the debate on the process of upgrading it seems more than legitimate, since we have to give concrete answers to all those involved in the promotion of their working lives, are still waiting anxiously on economic progress. For this we are committed to distrust and put that letter in the administration, complete the procedures for upgrading, not only inside the areas, but also in the passages between areas, as well as coveted by the plurality of recipients eligible .

In fact, our union, always present at the bargaining table, despite being a signatory to most of the agreements signed highlighted the emergence of elements of non-transparency and clarity "in relation the frameworks of the staff of the B field in the procedures of re-training and not yet completed process of regeneration of areas.

Although the Administration comes to the contrary, we believe that we have not proceeded rapidly in the scrolling lists, providing de facto replacement of dropouts, as envisaged by the Administration / Trade Unions. 's Feb. 8, 2006.

Too much time was used to identify places in addition to those established with the first band, to be allocated to appropriate processes within the redevelopment areas covering a total of 8736 seats, while new regulatory overlap and are a big boulder is intended to limit the organic MiBAC, as a result of indiscriminate cuts by governments that have followed.

If you add up to this framework agreement reached between the Administration and the Trade Unions signed on 17 September 2008, it was found that the additional availability occurred with reference to the number of units provided for in Presidential Decree 233/2007, were just 162 seats for the economic transitions from position B1 to B3 economic position, and 231 steps to the economic position B1 to B2 economic position, which despite having been distributed

equally between the regions and the skills identified as part of that agreement, however, was not possible to fully meet the needs of the Administration.

Subsequently, by agreement between the Administration / Trade Unions. signed on 18 February 2009, it was determined the ranking of staff to cover the deaths occurred in any capacity for the economic transitions from position B1 to B2 and B3 economic positions.

Even if steps were taken to cover the deaths of staff of area B, with the decrees of 2009 and 2010 have been nominated for appointment as an eligible 949 while they are still in course of improvement measures with which it is agreed that further 73 eligible and 28 from B1 to B3 from B1 to B2 eligible to fill the positions that became vacant in the meantime.

addition, following the subsequent agreement between the Administration / Trade Unions. signed on September 30, 2009 were published DD.DD. 16 and 24 September 2009 on the approval of the supervision of the rankings, partly changed as a result of the recalculation of seniority service of "ex Quarterly", with the simultaneous appointment of 98 units ex quarterly "in the profiles of the assistant supervisor, security, hospitality, communication, service to the public, operator supervision and acceptance of that fact, they went to record on the cessation of the supervisory intervening tained at 31 July 2010.

Furthermore, compared to our request for deregistration from the lists of employees who terminated employment in any capacity and updating of contextual same, the administration announced that the inconsistency reported in relatively on the rankings Area B of the former, you can not delete any candidate collocatosi potion in the classification list, unless it is found that was not meeting the requirements upon approval of the list, though on this subject the Administration ensures that when where there will be no creep will considered those candidates who will be ceased.

same time, the Administration is still mired in the implementation of the redevelopment by the former former Area B Area C, the coexistence of several appeals courts has inevitably delayed the proceedings with the result still nothing has been defined by the Lazio Regional Administrative Court and to conclude no later than December 31 of the examinations and the frameworks of all those who aspire to such a step, you should make a huge organizational effort, otherwise, unfortunately, we would be facing a serious issue to be considered as the me that the Reformation and Brunetta "the Finance Act No 122 conversion dl78" Article 9 provides that:

CHAPTER III -

CONTAINMENT EXPENDITURE ON PUBLIC USE, AND DISABILITY INSURANCE

Article 9. Containment of expenditure on public employment

For the years 2011, 2012 and 2013 the total salaries of individual employees, including managerial qualifications, including the treatment enhancement, provided by the respective jurisdictions government included in the consolidated income statement of the general government, as identified by the National Institute of Statistics (ISTAT), pursuant to paragraph 3 of Article 1 of Law Dec. 31 2009, No. 196, may not exceed, in any case, treatment ordinarily payable for the year 2010, net of effects arising from extraordinary events of wage dynamics, including changes in employees from any arrears conseguimen to different functions in During the year, without in any case the provisions of paragraph 21, third and fourth period, for career advancement, however denominated, maternity, sickness, missions abroad, the actual attendance at work, except as provided in paragraph 17 second sentence, and Article 8, paragraph 14.

Whose responsibility of the huge delay of a "never-ending story of a disaster redevelopment?

S and the inability of trade unions in the sector while arguing about everything they have lost sight of the real interests of workers that, despite what is stipulated in the contracts signed by them made it possible once again, the inapplicable standards on time, with its burden on the economic conditions of workers.

For a long time we have tried to represent the discomfort of workers on the "right of renewal" but as always, to our requests CGIL, CISL and UIL have preferred the contentiousness of the table and unfortunately this has led the administration to slow down over the years the implementation process training and retraining.

Whenever we launched a cry of alarm, anti-UNSA Confsal Culture has proceeded with the attempt to discredit, and undermines the image and the correctness of his actions, c how dare you for a long time we have noted the significant efforts of the other trade unions Confederations and not in a vain attempt to filibuster the work of the Cultural Heritage Confsal-UNSA, since despite not having any other material used to discredit any means, including sending "ad personam" message to display our Organization Auditors less proactive in public relations and not able to manage the trade union policies.

But this, with 'is now known, we are second to none, every day demonstrates the commitment with which we carry out with professionalism, loyalty and honesty in our work.

We can consistently provide the information to those we take to be informed promptly, produce their own press releases in real time, and a considerable flow of documents through our newsletters and trade union forums, including the monthly newsletter and the many e-mails aimed at the news of the day.

Our work can only be annoying, because our opponents want another model of "independent trade union", perhaps more unprepared and less efficient and more docile and mainly because no property, so they may keep doing the good and the bad weather, as well as the years have always done.

Anyway, continue to deal with them is just a waste of time, rather we think of our duties, and be welcomed on this issue for the excellent work already done by the National Coordination and the peripheral structures that resulted in a prompt and comprehensive information is disseminated through our mailing list to our site up to date.

That's what counts! nothing but talk! It is demonstrated by the many new members to our union, in the face of "Jurassic pachyderms' union confederations, which are nothing but unrelated to union bureaucrats reality and ideology is completely subservient to the remaining party, now completely obsolete and out of vogue.

Of this we must always take into account every day we see these characters and always be cautious about them because as you know, you are recognized entirely unreliable and extremely treacherous.

As for the next undertaking is of a general nature that specifically on regeneration, we'll have to attend the new prominence of Association and as always point out our position on behalf of thousands of workers we urge to defend their interests.

thanks for the excellent work that extend beyond that of course to all members and supporters, including all the "staff union, which consistently continue to pursue the program with the spirit of self-denial and completely against the grain.

Lied Zu Katesplayground

Bondi, new appointments announced by MiBAC

Minister for Arts and Culture, Sandro Bondi, has started the process of appointing some directors-general and central offices of the Ministry. In particular, the Minister

appointed:

Director General of Antiquities Dr. Luigi Malnati,
General Manager for the Landscape, Fine Art, architecture and contemporary art, Dr. Antonella Recchia Easter,
Regional Director for Cultural Heritage, Dr. Abruzzo. Fabrizio Magani,
Regional Director for the Cultural Heritage of Puglia Dr. Isabella Lapi
Regional Director for the Cultural Heritage of Friuli Dr. Giangiacomo Martines.

Fake I.d Place In Toronto On Yonge Street

No 47/10

MiBAC MUST ALSO ENSURE THE 'ACCESS TO DOCUMENTS AND ADMINISTRATIVE' the rule than the exception.

On 3 September 2010, the TAR of Lazio, in sentence no 32103, has declared favorably to the action brought by a participant in a contest at the MiBAC who, believing affected by the ranking, prepared and requested access to the curriculum of the other competitors.
Following the dismissal of silence 'instance, the above had been compelled to resort to the TAR of Lazio, then in the first sentence stated once again that access to administrative acts is the rule and the denial is the' exception .
Having said this, another interesting consideration is that: 'The access may in fact be excluded solely and exclusively in the cases expressly provided for in' art. 24 L. 241/1990, including those not covered in question. "
"Thus, access to documents produced by the candidates (as well as to reports, the evaluation sheets and the works) can not be rejected by the administration because:
Always on access to administrative measures, and in relation to the refusal , also have the comfort of a previous sentence, provided the TAR of Lazio, 12 November 2009 following an appeal against an order issued by 'INPS.
Returning to our ministry, it is now clear that with regard to access to administrative documents should resign as well established in law, especially with regard to the frequent denial that opposes the applicants and also because the law Access to administrative records will prevail over the right to privacy of third parties.
MiBAC, if he will continue to succumb to trial will therefore do well to adapt because, as demonstrated by this ruling, "In relation to the conduct of the Ministry that, almost twenty years since the L. n.241/1990, forced the question to refer the matter to the courts to achieve a peaceful law and reimbursement of expenses, according to general rules. Finally he was sentenced following the unsuccessful recognized € 2000.000 € 500.00 in expenses (and I pay ...).
In conclusion, it is' time to stop with this attitude persistent part of MiBAC act to deny 'access to administrative documents
For reference, the sentence in question is transcribed.

N. 32103/2010 REG.SEN.
N. 03367/2010 REG.RIC.


ITALIAN REPUBLIC ON BEHALF OF THE ITALIAN PEOPLE

The Regional Administrative Court of Lazio
(Section Second Quater)

gives the following



Judgement on the appeal to General Ledger number 3367 of 2010, proposed by Giuseppe Ruiz , represented and defended by the lawyer. Michael Damiani, with an address by Michael Damian in Rome, Via Mordini, 14;

against

Ministry of Heritage and Activities' Cultural, represented and defended by the state, by law domiciled in Rome, via the Portuguese, 12;

against

Paolo D'Angeli, Angela Di Ciommo, Nicolazzo Vincenzo, Antonio Tarasco, Paola Passarelli, Muratori Giorgia , Tommasino Mario, Alessandra Franzone, Pasqualetti George Benedetto Luigi Compagnoni, Antonio Parente, Elisabetta Piccioni,

to cancel the instance

REJECTION OF SILENCE OF 3.2.2010 FOR ACCESS TO DOCUMENTS UNDER ART. 25 LN 241/90.
Since the action with its annexes;
Since the entry of appearance in court of the Ministry of Heritage and Activities' Cultural;
view of the briefs;
Taking all of the acts of the case;
Speaker in chambers on May 11, 2010 Cons. Umberto Realfonzo and heard the parties to the defenders as specified in the minutes;
held and considered the facts and law as follows.

FACT

The applicant, who had participated in the competition for public examinations and qualifications to five places of Director of Administration, issued a decree Directorial March 1, 2007, although it had successfully placed on the list, was the winner of that contest. By application
notified 3 February 2010 the applicant, motivated by explicit reference to the need to protect their subjective positions, as a result has requested access to the qualifications and documents evidencing the securities in preference to their competitors ranked eleventh in the ranking of the competition.
The appeal, duly notified to all counterparties, is entrusted to the complaint of infringement of Article. 97 of the Constitution and art. 22 et seq. of 7.8.1990, n. 241: knowledge of the acts required of the competition was essential to ensure the protection of its legal position, it remains necessary to rule on every aspect of confidentiality.
The Administration is only formally in court.
Call the Chamber of the Council concerned at the request of the applicant's counsel, was retained in the decision.

LAW

The appeal is based.
As is known, based on general principles, access to administrative acts is the rule and the denial is the exception.
Access may in fact be excluded solely and exclusively in the cases expressly provided for in art. 24 L. No 241/1990, which did not fall into one word.
Thus, access to documents produced by the candidates (as well as to reports, the evaluation sheets and the works) can not be rejected by the administration because:
- the right of access to administrative documents prevail over the right to privacy third parties (see TAR Lazio Rome sect. III, November 12, 2009, No 11094);
- must be excluded at the roots, compared to those documents, the need for confidentiality to protect third parties, and because the competitors taking part in the selection, have apparently agreed to compete in a competition in which the comparison of values \u200b\u200bis the essence, and because such acts, once acquired for the procedure, leaving the personal sphere of the participants (see TAR Campania Naples, sect. V, 09 February 2010, n. 726);
- there is no need to await completion of that, because there is no need for the injury is made with concrete and then it becomes a present interest to appeals, because the candidate is still an interest of self-knowledge of these acts, especially where the person concerned has requested copies of documents, such as curriculum, qualifications, etc.. in relation to which there is no conflicting requirements of confidentiality (see Council of State, sect. VI, 21 May 2009, n. 3147; TAR Liguria Genova, sez. II, 25 November 2009, n. 3460);
In conclusion the action is based and must be accepted and must be declared the applicant's right to access to required documentation within 15 days following the announcement in an administrative or notification of this decision.
In relation to the conduct of the Ministry that, almost twenty years since Law n.241/1990, forced the question to refer the matter to the courts to obtain a right disputed charges, according to general rules. following the unsuccessful and are paid in a total of € 2000.000 € 500.00 in expenses.

PQM

the Regional Administrative Court of Lazio-II, Part ^ - c:
1. Allows the appeal against the implied rejection, and the effect declaring the obligation of the Ministry to rule on the request for access to the applicant within the time and manner of the reasons given;
2. Condemns the State to pay the court costs that are paid in a total of 500.00 to € 2,000.00 in costs.
Order that this sentence is carried out by the administrative authority.
Decided in Rome in chambers on May 11, 2010 with the assistance of Judges:
Lucia Tosti, President
Umberto Realfonzo, Advisor, extenders
Alessandro Tomassetti, Councillor

FILED IN OFFICE The
09/03/2010
(Art. 55, L. 27/4/1982, n. 186)
THE SECRETARY

Baptism Reception In Miami

PRESS RELEASE NO 46/10

TO REVISE THE REQUIREMENTS IN THE 'CALL' OF STRESS ON THE APPLICATION FOR PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCEDURES The service concession expired on September 15.

widely requested the cancellation of all notices in self-defense

REJECTED THE RACE

FOR RESTAURANTS IN ROME MUSEUMS

According to the administrative courts of the TAR of Lazio and the conditions imposed by Notice of solicitation Museums of the Roman restaurant services are not respectful of the competition, because they have excessive requirements!

The ruling is due on appeal by a private company could not participate because the requirements for selection for the award of the catering services of the Museums of Rome too had the condition " I managed between dining with the same mark for three years. "

The judges noted that the requirements for participation in contracts should not be illogical, arbitrary, unnecessary or redundant and must be respectful "of the principle of proportionality, which requires that each identified requirement is both necessary and appropriate to the aims pursued."

In other words, the contracting should pay attention to creating "the least possible disruption to the economic activities" and the notice shall not constitute a "material breach of the principles of free competition, par playing field, non-discrimination and transparency. "

Oddly enough, it seems that both the Tar aware of the unreasonable demands conformity to what is reported by this union to contracting in Rome, Naples and Florence in the month of September (see ns. Press Release, September 23) as well explicit reasons that those " an unreasonable restriction of competition .

We believe that the Ministry should take note of the sentence and to avoid further disputes with consequent impact on the tender (the same issue is also being Antitrust) set aside in order to provide self-help calls to amend the said vice (besides all the inconsistencies already mentioned).

Sincerely

The National Coordination

CONFSAL UNSA-CULTURAL

For reference, the sentence in question is transcribed.

N. 32717/2010 REG.SEN.

N. 07837/2010 REG.RIC.

ITALIAN REPUBLIC

IN THE NAME OF THE ITALIAN PEOPLE

The Regional Administrative Court of Lazio

(Section Second Quater)

gives the following

JUDGEMENT

under Articles. 60 and 74 cod. proc. Admin.;

on the use of general register number 7837 of 2010 proposed by:

Soc Expo 2004 Srl, represented and defended by the lawyer. Sardo Monica, Sergio Caracciolo, with an address at Sergio Caracciolo in Rome, Via Lazio, 20 / C;

against

Ministry of Heritage and Activities' Culture, represented and defended by the state, legally domiciled in Rome, via the Portuguese, 12;

to cancel

the view of the Ministry of Heritage and Culture, Special Division for heritage historical, artistic and ethno-anthropological and the Museums of the city of Rome, to urge the IGC 05019752DF application form, published in Gazette, 5th Special Series, June 30, 2010 and related documents;

viewed the application and its annexes;

Since the entry of appearance in court of the Ministry of Heritage and Culture;

view of the briefs;

Taking all of the acts of the case;

Speaker in chambers on the day on October 6, 2010 Cons. Umberto Realfonzo and heard the parties to the defenders as specified in the minutes;

feel the same parties pursuant to art. 60 cod. proc. Admin.;

held and considered the facts and law as follows.

fact and law

The Board, in advance, believes that, after hearing about the parties must The views can be defined in closed session with ruling in a simplified form, since the conditions stated in art. 60 of Legislative Decree no. July 2, 2010, No 104, at least twenty days have elapsed since the last notification of the action, respecting no problems resulting in contradictory and sufficiency of the evidence adduced.

the appeal for annulment of the "stress the application form for the concession for six years. of cafeteria services at various museums for a total of € 6.199000 ml.

1. outset must be considered preliminary objection of inadmissibility, introduced orally to the Council Chamber, the state representative for the applicant lacks challenge to a notice of interest for which would not have made the application form.

The exception must be rejected.

must, however, as noted when the participation in the procedure for the award of a contract is precluded by the band, there is an interest in its determination to impose no-show, regardless of the application.

In such cases, in fact, since the submission of the results in a formality inevitably followed by an act of exclusion, a result similar to that of an original foreclosure and so devoid of genuine practical use (see the State Council, sect. V, 02 August 2010, No. 5069) within the limits of reasonableness and proportionality, there are therefore doubts about the eligibility of the full burden.

2. the order of importance should be examined in the first, second and third grounds of appeal. By the first plea, the appellant complains the illegality of the incorporation in one batch concession.

The first reason is not convincing.

In principle, the decision to include or not in a single contract or several lots, a package of services to be delivered by invitation to tender relates to the technical appraisal of the administration (see Council of State , sect. V, March 20, 2007, n. 1331).

In this case, in relation to the absolute homogeneity of the services, the contested provision of the notice is therefore fully legitimate.

3. With the second and third plea alleging the illegality of the additional requirement on the request to have run "three places to eat" with the same mark for three years (depending on profile) thus inhibiting the possibility of participating in or using the Ati ' availment.

The reason is well founded.

It must be remembered that, pursuant to art. 30 comma 3 °, d.lg. No 12 April 2006 163, in calls for tender for the provision of services "... choice of the dealer must comply with the principles might be derived from the Treaty and the general principles relating to public contracts and, in particular, the principles of transparency, adequate publicity, non-discrimination, equal treatment, mutual recognition, proportionality, after informal notice to which they are invited at least five competitors, if there are qualified individuals in this number in the subject matter of the concession, and with predetermined selection criteria. "

In this context, therefore, for the purpose of verification of the technical capacity, limited the list referred to artt.41 and 42 of the Decree. n.163 not constitute for the contracting, a direct link.

However, in relation to the reference to the principles of the EU Treaty determinations concerning personal qualifications for participation in contracts should not be illogical, arbitrary, unnecessary or wasteful and should be respectful of the "principle of proportionality, which requires that each identified requirement is both necessary and appropriate to the aims pursued .

The effective exercise of discretion must therefore be functionally consistent with the combination of public and private interests involved in the public auction, and must respect the principles of the Code of the contracts.

In the selection of the participation requirements, therefore, the observed non-discrimination principle requires that the awarding body must resort to those which cause the least disruption to the pursuit of economic activity.

Ultimately the entire system of the opinion should not therefore constitute a material breach of the principles of free competition and level playing field, transparency of non-discrimination in art. 2. first paragraph of the decree. n.163/2006, SM.

In this case the interest declared by the Administration on the need for a "unified management" of these services on a number of centers, museums, appears unrelated to the request for prior period of three dining "in the same brand. "

The use of the mark or brand would indeed could be considered as a "bargaining clause" of the message, ie a contractual obligation for the future of the consultant contract award, but could not incorporate any particular additional requirement compared to the turnover of a trader who operates (or deemed preferable to work for his company's choice) on the market with "brand" different.

The imposing a single brand for the various operations is a variable of the procedure which involves complete failure to participate in the race of persons whose sales also approved limits.

In essence, the clause is illegal because it constitutes an unreasonable restriction on competition, and that nothing corresponds to no interest in the contracting.

Ultimately warning about the appeal on that point is illegal and must be annulled.

4. In these profiles, which are absorbed in the remaining complaints, therefore the action is founded.

For the effect to be pronounced the annulment of the contested measure.

expenses, pursuant to art. 26 of Legislative Decree no. July 2, 2010, No 104, following the unsuccessful and are paid in € 2000.00 in favor of the appellant.

PQM

the Lazio Regional Administrative Court (Second Chamber Quater)

pronouncing definitively on the action, as suggested in the epigraph,

1. upholds the claim referred to in the headnote and the effect cancels the decision referred to in the epigraph.

2. Condemns the Administration to pay court costs in € 2.000,00.

Order that the above is carried out by the administrative authority.

Decided in Rome in the chambers on day 6 October 2010 with the intervention of the judiciary:

Angelo Scafidi, President

Umberto Realfonzo, Advisor, extenders

Stefania Santoleri, Councillor

FILED IN OFFICE

The 07/10/2010

THE SECRETARY

(Art. 89, para. 3, no. proc. Admin.)